
ISD Ezwal
ISD Community Communications Liaisons
2303

|
Posted - 2014.09.22 09:33:00 -
[1] - Quote
Pro TIps wrote:Not to tread on the "discussion of forum moderation" too much, but there was a cool thread the other day from Lazerhawks that was entirely about a W-space siege and it got kicked to some other sub-forum.
Yet two weeks ago, CCP partnered with that eve-bet site to basically manufacture a rare super kill with hopes of generating some interest in both the event (clearly successul as 4000+ in system) and maybe in getting people to re-subscribe or whatever.
How does the CCP PR machine not communicate to ISD that a thread about sieging someone's hole is fun and interesting to read; and the kind of thing some players might aspire to participate in? They should want to elevate news like this, not bury it in a different sub-forum to cut off discussion.
So my point here is, they spent a bunch of dev effort basically trying to promote more W-space PVP, but there is a thread telling about a siege and instead of going, hey, here is players having fun (at least the Lazerhawks side) they fail to recognize the potential upside of that and actually bury it. Yes, it was an interesting thread, yes it concerned Wormhole play. That said, I would hardly call moving it to Crime & Punishment 'burying', as that part of the forum is at least just as active as the Wormhole section, if not more. If the OP of that thread did not want it to get moved or at least severely edited, he should not have included the killmails. If you think the forum rules on posting killmails are somehow wrong or obsolete, please feel free to post a proposal for change of those rules in the Features & Ideas Discussion part of the forum, keeping you proposal firmly away from discussing (specific) forum moderation. CCL does not make the rules, we enforce them.
On that note, if CCP were to post a thread about a fight containing killmails in the OP and it would not have been posted in C&P (or in CCP's case, also not in EVE Information Portal), it would just as well get moved by me. Or have those killmail links removed.
I have written this rather uncommon explanation as I have witnessed some antagonism against forum moderation in the Wormhole section of the forum lately, quite often originating from posters having only a marginal understanding of the forum rules. Please do not continue discussing forum moderation in this thread, or on any part of the forum. If you are perceiving a problem with ISD behaviour on the forum or are disagreeing with the way (your) posts are being moderated, please feel free to read the CCP policies and follow the procedure found under the header 'Complaints'.
Besides, next time I see any of you in W-space while logged in with my playing main, I will do my utmost best to sacrifice you to Bob. Or, of course, die trying.... ISD Ezwal Vice Admiral Community Communication Liaisons (CCLs) Interstellar Services Department |